“As tough, brassy, bossy Jersey girl Mary Delgado, Valli’s first wife, and mother of the child whose death will eventually shatter his world, Rachel Pantazis creates powerful moments in her scenes with Maguire’s Valli. Her duet with Maguire of “My eyes adored you” musically mourns the demise of Valli’s and Mary’s marriage, and is filled with all the pain, regret, sorrow, and anger that comes from a shattered marriage. Maguire and Pantazis make magic together with this number.”